Opinion: What Fauci's emails reveal -- and what they don't

by 24USATVJune 3, 2021, 4 a.m. 18

Megan Ranney , MD, MPH, is an associate professor of emergency medicine; co-founder of GetUsPPE; and a CNN medical analyst. The opinions expressed in this commentary are her own. View more opinion on CNN.

(CNN) This week, 3,234 pages of emails from Dr. Anthony Fauci, the chief medical adviser to the President, were released through a Freedom Of Information Act request. I'm still trying to digest them all, as I expect many people are.

At times, it feels like reading someone's diary, albeit a post-modernist, redacted diary with a non-linear timeline. At other times, it feels like looking at the celebrity photos on the front pages of People magazine: "He felt that way, too?!"

The emails may not always be exciting, but they're real. There is no hagiography here. And we're lucky to get this inside view of how our country's scientific enterprise -- and its intersection with the rest of our federal government -- figured out what Covid-19 was, how it spread, how to stop it and how to communicate about it.

For many of us, it's fascinating to follow how scientific knowledge accumulated, evolved and was presented to the public. Some who read these emails will doubtlessly find "errors" -- things that have since those early days been proven false -- but I would caution everyone, including Fauci's detractors currently scouring them for missteps, to remember that these are errors only in hindsight; at the time, no one knew what was the truth.

Equally worthy of attention are Fauci's clear leadership skills. Over the course of these 3,200+ pages, we can watch him manage a tremendous bureaucracy and its intersection with the executive branch. These emails show a man who is trying to move quickly but accurately. He maintains an impressive curiosity and willingness to at least stay aware of out-of-the-box ideas.

In March of 2020, for example, he forwarded a correspondence about the possible Covid-19 immunity of indigenous people harvesting guano (bat excrement), as well as an idea from a psychiatry professor about using the antibiotic minocycline to slow viral replication. He commented on an email from a Swedish psychiatrist, "There may be nothing to this, but we should at least be aware." And in April of that year, he told a persistent doctor with multiple ideas for possible antiviral agents, "You are not being ignored."

It is clear from the consideration he gave these theories, and the care with which he addressed the public, that Fauci spent time trying to digest the latest information before opining to the nation.

I also, of course, note what is missing -- namely, many details from the White House Task Force. We get just little hints: "Let us discuss this when we are together at the 4:00 PM TF Meeting," for example. That history will have to wait. Only occasionally does any frustration with the federal government's response show up in the emails, such as when he is commenting on current Covid-19 tests being "misleading" or defending his public presence to fellow public health scientists: "I genuflect to no one but science and always, always speak my mind when it comes to public health."

Finally, in between the lines, we watch him manage this pandemic as a human. There are emails where he is clearly overwhelmed, forwarding media request after speaking request to his assistants at the Office of the Chief of Staff. (One has to wonder: who wouldn't be overwhelmed by this number of requests?)

There are emails where he is tremendously kind, thanking people for their service, telling staff to "stay well and safe" or complimenting folks on well-written papers and columns.

Again and again, he responds to concerned citizens, scientists and journalists with: "Thank you for your note." He pays attention both to people he knows -- apologetically telling Ralph Nader at 7 p.m. on a Sunday, "I receive over 1000 e-mails per day and even with staff screening, I do not see them for days." -- and to those he probably doesn't. There are times when he's funny, times when he's frustrated and times when he's clearly exhausted, admitting that he's simply too tired to make sense of something.

Throughout, his on-paper voice sounds just like his television voice. He is humble, curious and committed. My takeaway? He is just like us -- or, at least, he's how most of us like to imagine ourselves to be, on our best days.

I look forward to reading more.


Related Articles


Lakers' Caruso arrested for marijuana possession

by 24USATVJune 23, 2021, 8 a.m.2

Scherzer miffed as umpires inspect him 3 times

by 24USATVJune 23, 2021, 7 a.m.2

Top prospect Wander Franco homers in MLB debut for Rays

by 24USATVJune 23, 2021, 6 a.m.2

A look back at Britney Spears' conservatorship

by 24USATVJune 23, 2021, 6 a.m.2

Lakers' Alex Caruso arrested for possession of marijuana

by 24USATVJune 23, 2021, 5 a.m.2